Top class! Very well explained, good examples, excellent learning material, practical exercises, and lots and lots of room for further personal study! Well done guys, and especially Xavier! Cheers!
An absolutely awesome introduction to Audio Signal Processing. The additive introduction of new concepts is capable of teaching any beginner this topic which ordinarily is difficult to understand.
por Yu T W•
This course is what i have been longing for :)))
por Jenny L•
This course is amazing I wish I can give 6 stars
por Amauri B S•
Very good material! Very interesting subject!
por Ghislain S•
I learned a lot and had fun at the same time
por OMAR Y G•
best course to apply your math knowledment
por Martin B•
Very interesting and well explained
por Jackie D•
awesome course on music application
por ruchi g•
every topic is very well explained
great course, learned a lot for it
por Liu S•
Very interesting and useful class
por jesús r g•
All the course is great
por Nikhil N•
A fantastic course!
por Gennaro G•
por Payne K•
por JUAN M M G•
por Matthew Z•
por Alexander A S G•
por Hiroki N•
The course itself is very nice. However, the level of participants seems to have a significant problem. Some participants are not used to reviewing. They often lack an appropriate background in reviewing others, and give a bad grade for the A++ level submissions (for instance, I had A++ for related courses at University of Washington, and I am hiring a CCRMA graduate at my lab).
Possibly this could be a challenge for MOOC, yet obviously peer-reviewing by participants doesn't work fine for some topics, especially when some participants have a problem in understanding lecture materials.
I think there should be an opportunity for a rebuttal and moderators should handle it.
Really well crafted course. Assignments were challenging, but they make for a great learning experience. Also great is that the lectures walk you through the theory, the application, and programming aspects of the topic. Recommended for anyone who wants to learn about the Fourier Transform and about audio processing.
The only "but" is that the staff doesn't participate in the forums anymore (the last messages from them are like 2 years old). This wasn't a big deal for me as I didn't really participate much, but it gives the feeling that the course is not well cared for anymore.
por Daman A•
Assignments are easily doable without any application of real analysis skills. You guys should actually ask us to build certain parts of your models so that we achieve that level of skill.
por AKULA J•
A course which gives an overview of many transforms each with a theory, demonstrative and programming classes with quizzes but the assignments could have been a less difficulty level.
por David A•
Excellent material for an interesting subject. The video lectures are very good. The course does need some updates for Python3 and associated libraries to stay current.
por Farouk E•
I have questions that I would like to ask, but it seems that I can't access discussion forms for some reason.