Outstanding Course! I could always count on Prof.Jianbo to crunch some of the most complex and confusing parts of the course into a much easier understandable language.
This is quite challenging course. So far, this is the course with the largest amount of material, I wish the class will be split into two courses.
por NICHOLAS P•
Interesting material, the last programming assignment was very challenging. Lots of topics covered, a good introduction.
por Ruslan A•
Very interesting and useful course. Professors give a lot of information. However, some explanations are not very clear.
por Tim O•
Lots of good content, good explanations, and good pictures to explain things. I enjoyed the assignments too
por Mohammad H•
very useful course. However it needs some supplementary materials in math. also more solved examples.
very informative. the course is very demanding, due to very long lectures it is hard to stay in pace.
por Jesus F•
Good course, but assignmets are too long, difficult and with no much help. Workload is overpassed
por Xiaotao G•
It is hard compared to previous courses and need more time on it. But quite helpful!
por Rahul D•
I was expecting Some implementation of the SFM pipeline from OpenCV or OpenMVG.
por Mike Z•
Really good topic but the material can be improved a lot more.
And it's free !
por Shubham W•
Excellent course!! Especially Bundle Adjustment was covered in good details.
por Ricardo A R•
Need more videos for final weeks, hard to follow last week of the course
por Daniel C•
To put it simply: Shi's content is good and Danniilidis' content is bad.
por Aman B•
It was interesting, but damn the lectures are never ending.
a bit difficult to understand, anyway,finally passed!
por Ákos G•
Good course, but the video subtitles are garbage.
por xiao z•
need specific feed backs for those quizzes!!!
por li q•
The lecture notes should be better organized.
a little difficult for me,but learn a lot!
por Hussain M A•
Hard course but lots of good insight.
por Martin X•
The courses are good and helpful.
por Ali M H•
Thank you Professors !
por Fredo P C•
por Daniel S•
This course could use some help. It's a very interesting and important topic and is also difficult, but it could be explained better and the tie in between the lecture videos, quizzes and homework assignments could also be better. Some of the quiz questions are not answerable from reviewing the lecture notes and require outside knowledge of linear algebra and rotation mathematics. The assignments should also be better defined and set up so that there is incremental feedback available for the intermediate steps. For example, the last week's assignment has 5 steps, each of which requires a Matlab function to be written. In many online courses, there are "correct" intermediate results given so that each step can be verified before proceeding to the next step. In this assignment, there is not much feedback until you get to the third or fourth step and even then it's not the best. I had an error in one of the functions, but the problem feedback (photo comparisons) showed it as being OK until I submitted it for grading. It's important, since there's no instructor feedback , to provide some means of checking if you're doing things correctly.Some of the terminology used would be more clear if it was standardized; sometimes coordinates are x and y, sometimes u and v, there's also u1, u2, u3 and things like X = [x,y,z,w] and x = [u,v,w]. Its often quite difficult to know what's being referred to it's called x. I did learn a lot from this course, but it could have been a lot easier.
por Rishabh B•
The course is a very good overall description of the Perception field. The part I really liked is that there was no haste or a concept just superficially discussed - lectures are long and detailed. The presentation of lectures especially from Prof. Jianbo Shi are excellent - to represent Matrices in colours and give a intuitive sense of every formula(especially the Jacobians and treating the image blending process as painting) .
The bad part of this course is that pronunciations of faculties could be a little unclear and hence a very good transcript is required - which in this course is not upto the mark. There were few mistakes on the slides and should be rectified atleast in the pdf of the slides. What this means is that we have to go through some frustration while watching the video first time which gradually improves on second or third view. Also, there is absolutely no participation of teaching staff. A good content should be supplemented with assistance to further enhance learning experience. Few doubts because of this remains unclear and I wish I could have got this sorted in this class.